Key Points:

  • Early reporters (May fiscal quarters) doing much better than expected
  • Second-quarter total net income expected to be down 36.8% year over year
  • Staples only sector expected to post positive growth in second quarter
  • Six sectors expected to decline more than 25%
  • Financials expected to rebound after disastrous 2008
  • Median EPS growth in second quarter expected to be -14.8%
  • Third-quarter expected to be down 22.3% year over year
  • Full year 2009 expected to fall 13.7%, which implies strong growth in fourth quarter
  • Bottom-up estimate for S&P 500 is now $59.60 in 2009 and is starting to rise.
  • S&P 500 now expected to earn $74.09 in 2010

Total Net Income Growth

  • Total net income for S&P 500 expect to fall 36.8% from a year ago
  • Early reporters down just 14.1%; Discretionary sector the only gainer.
  • Materials, Telecom, and Energy expected to tumble by 67% or more
  • Staples expected to lead by standing still (up 0.5%); Health Care to post just a 4.6% decline
Total Net Income Growth (Reported)
Sector Q4 ’08 A Q1 ’09 A Q2 ’09 A Q3 ’09 E 2008 A 2009 E 2010 E
Cons. Disc. 0.32% 17.64% 24.20% -21.18% 0.81% 10.78% 18.54%
Cons. Stap. 0.30% -18.72% -7.01% -5.99% 4.02% 3.65% 10.00%
Materials 113.28% 19.43% -14.43% -160.17% 82.00% 21.28% 0.95%
Technology -8.36% -17.13% -17.90% -15.10% 13.46% -2.18% 39.32%
Industrials 2.92% -75.32% -56.03% -66.63% -13.37% -50.94% 31.12%
Financials -146.87% -173.95% -142.55% -141.19% -37.71% -187.42% -97.05%
S&P -2.45% -13.07% -14.11% -21.69% 6.66% -3.91% 23.87%
Total Net Income (Reported)
Sector Q2 ’09 Q2 ’08 Q1 ’09 Q1 ’08
Technology $2,150 $2,619 $1,462 $1,765
Cons. Disc. $1,453 $1,170 $1,819 $1,546
Cons. Stap. $1,355 $1,457 $1,431 $1,761
Materials $694 $811 $1,195 $1,000
Industrials $200 $455 $97 $393
Financials -$86 $202 -$177 $239
S&P $5,766 $6,713 $5,828 $6,704
Total Net Income Growth (Not Reported)
Sector Q4 ’08 A Q1 ’09 A Q2 ’09 E Q3 ’09 E 2008 A 2009 E 2010 E
Cons. Stap. 1.65% -5.17% 1.11% -1.78% 15.46% -1.13% 10.28%
Health Care 8.22% 0.52% -4.64% -4.37% 12.52% -3.04% 9.81%
Utilities -0.55% -1.23% -12.18% 0.70% 1.89% -1.90% 8.63%
Financials -1019.60% 6.64% -12.38% 288.02% -107.07% -610.59% 58.26%
Industrial -20.29% -34.83% -40.54% -33.22% 1.00% -31.06% 8.07%
Cons. Disc. -102.50% -50.43% -42.02% -7.80% -31.56% -7.38% 42.31%
Technology -17.99% -26.90% -50.19% -23.53% 18.48% -17.80% 18.97%
Energy -26.01% -60.57% -67.00% -64.32% 21.87% -58.44% 43.83%
Telecom -18.08% -18.86% -69.89% -15.82% -5.68% -19.42% 6.74%
Materials -91.18% -87.68% -84.27% -70.21% -18.60% -72.05% 130.78%
S&P -60.38% -27.71% -37.64% -22.37% -19.10% -13.68% 24.31%
Total Net Income Growth (Combined)
Sector Q4 ’08 A Q1 ’09 A Q2 ’09 E Q3 ’09 E 2008 A 2009 E 2010 E
Cons. Stap. 1.53% -6.34% 0.50% -2.05% 15.47% -1.55% 10.26%
Health Care 8.22% 0.52% -4.64% -4.37% 12.52% -3.04% 9.81%
Utilities -0.55% -1.23% -12.18% 0.70% 1.89% -1.90% 8.63%
Financials -992.86% 4.20% -13.51% 269.69% -106.73% -629.80% 59.41%
Cons. Disc. -96.07% -43.46% -36.57% -10.24% -27.34% -6.93% 38.87%
Industrial -19.82% -35.61% -40.84% -33.80% 0.54% -31.41% 8.42%
Technology -17.42% -26.25% -47.16% -22.97% 19.15% -17.48% 20.55%
Energy -26.01% -60.57% -67.00% -64.32% 21.87% -58.44% 43.83%
Telecom -18.08% -18.86% -69.89% -15.82% -5.68% -19.42% 6.74%
Materials -81.98% -74.07% -77.59% -69.94% -13.36% -64.71% 93.76%
S&P -58.59% -27.17% -36.83% -22.34% -18.07% -13.70% 24.29%

Scorecard and Median EPS Growth

  • The median surprise is high at 6.51%; six positive surprises per disappointment
  • Just 24 reports in; all May fiscal period ends
  • Consumer Discretionary off to a great start at 9-and-0 and15.4% median growth
  • Median EPS expected to fall by 14.8% in the quarter
Second-Quarter Scorecard (Surprises)
Sector %
Reported
Median %
Surprise
# Pos
Surprise
# Neg
Surprise
# Match
Cons. Disc. 11.11% 11.76% 9 0 0
Healthcare 11.32% 1.22% 3 2 1
Materials 3.57% 6.84% 1 0 0
Tech 8.00% 1.16% 3 1 2
Industrial 1.72% 25.49% 1 0 0
Financial 1.25% 35.71% 1 0 0
S&P 500 4.80% 6.51% 18 3 3
Second-Quarter EPS Growth (Reported)
Sector 2Q ’09 (A) 3Q ’09 (E) 2008 (A) 2009 (E) 2010 (E)
Cons. Disc. 15.38% 8.20% -3.05% 5.85% 10.27%
Healthcare -4.88% -1.84% 11.58% 3.67% 0.00%
Materials -13.79% 133.33% 82.00% 21.28% 0.95%
Tech -29.51% -26.39% 9.52% -19.82% 12.62%
Industrial -55.86% -67.48% -35.33% -24.14% 31.12%
Financial -142.80% -129.70% -37.71% -187.40% -97.05%
S&P 500 -4.88% -1.94% 7.63% 1.82% 10.05%
Second-Quarter EPS Growth (Not Reported)
Sector 2Q ’09 (E) 3Q ’09 (E) 2008 (A) 2009 (E) 2010 (E)
Healthcare 5.31% 5.36% 16.98% 12.55% 10.87%
Utilities 3.96% 0.00% 9.28% 3.79% 7.75%
Cons. Stap. -0.94% 5.32% 12.66% 8.33% 9.67%
Telecom -1.98% -12.00% 25.40% 1.44% 7.38%
Tech -16.67% 0.00% 19.13% 14.64% 13.44%
Cons. Disc. -17.75% -2.57% 11.81% -11.37% 11.88%
Financial -19.15% 9.64% 7.84% -21.20% 8.22%
Industrial -21.33% -12.61% 16.92% 13.64% 9.87%
Materials -34.31% 17.78% 12.20% -4.89% 14.06%
Energy -64.03% -24.49% 12.35% 21.29% 16.09%
S&P 500 -14.76% 0.00% 13.80% 6.40% 10.76%

The Zacks Revisions Ratio: 2009

  • Revisions ratio for full S&P 500 down to 1.04 from 1.29
  • Reverses steady climb in the ratio for over 3 months
  • Three sectors in positive territory: Consumer Sectors, Tech lead
  • Six sectors in negative territory; Industrials the weakest
  • Now into neutral territory for the S&P 500 as a whole
  • Industrials, Materials continue to see estimates cut
  • Ratio of firms with rising to falling mean estimates declines to 0.94 from 1.04
  • Total number of revisions (4-week total) down to 1,472 from 1,653 (-10.9%)
  • Increases down to 751 from 930 (-19.2%), cuts down to 721 from 723 (-0.0%)
  • Total revisions activity approaching low for the quarter

The revisions ratio reversed course, falling after a long string of steady increases. The reversal brought it from the abysmal lows of 0.20 last winter (i.e. 5 cuts for every increase) to a high of 1.29 two weeks ago. Last winter, in individual sectors, the cuts were often in excess of 10:1.

The current reading is on a very low number of total revisions, which is quite normal for this time of the quarter. However, it is sort of like a stock that moves on low volume. It’s good if the stock moves up, but you have less conviction about its significance than if it is on high volume.

Tech has moved up substantially in the revisions ratio rankings in large part due to the strength in the Chip industry. Some of the real standouts in terms of large numbers of estimate increases leading to very large increases in mean estimates are National Semiconductor (NSM) and Texas Instruments (TXN).

The strength in Staples was lead by General Mills (GIS). However it is a sector where the estimate changes do not tend to be dramatic. Two other notables that had many more increases than cuts, but small changes in the mean estimate, were Colgate-Palmolive (CL) and Kroger (KR). The one firm in the sector that was noteworthy in heading south was Walgreens (WAG).

The weakness in the Industrial sector was most apparent in some of the transportation related companies, like FedEx (FDX) and Southwest Airline (LUV). Paccar (PCAR) was also very weak.

Sector Avg. 4wk EPS
Change (FY1)
Revisions
Ratio
Firms With
FY1 EPS
Increase
Firms With
FY1 EPS
Decrease
Technology 0.88% 2.49 36 22
Consumer Staple 0.31% 2.15 25 8
Consumer Disc -2.38% 1.52 30 33
Telecom 0.98% 1.17 4 4
Financial Services -0.54% 0.87 33 40
Energy 0.94% 0.71 18 22
Materials -0.45% 0.70 8 11
Health Care -0.41% 0.65 21 25
Utilities 0.64% 0.50 12 17
Industrials -1.79% 0.38 17 31
S&P 500 -0.46% 1.04 204 213

The Zacks Revisions Ratio: 2010

  • Revisions much stronger for 2010 than 2009
  • Revisions ratio down to 1.27 from 1.34
  • Tech showing best estimate momentum for 2010
  • Industrials and Utilities getting cut.
  • Ratio of rising to falling mean estimates rises to 1.05 from 1.30
  • Total revisions activity nearing lows for the quarter
  • Total number of revisions falls to 1,199 from 1,350 (-11.2%)
  • Estimate increases falls to 670 from 774 (-13.4%), cuts fall to 529 from 576 (-8.2%).

Chips lead the tech sector. Sprint (S) was the standout in the Telecom sector.

Sector Avg. 4wk EPS
Change (FY2)
Revisions
Ratio
Firms With
FY2 EPS
Increase
Firms With
FY2 EPS
Decrease
Technology 1.14% 3.07 32 26
Telecom 1.41% 2.25 3 4
Consumer Staples 0.11% 1.89 21 13
Consumer Discr -0.56% 1.54 30 30
Financial Services 2.50% 1.27 41 31
Health Care -0.16% 0.96 24 25
Materials -0.68% 0.81 10 11
Energy 0.65% 0.81 22 18
Industrials -0.35% 0.70 18 24
Utilities -0.40% 0.61 10 19
S&P 500 0.44% 1.27 211 201

Earnings Shares and P/Es

  • Earnings Shares, including historical, based on current make up of S&P 500
  • Health Care expected to take earnings crown from Energy in 2009 and keep it in 2010
  • Energy’s earnings share expected to plunge to 11.2% from 23.2%
  • Financials’ 2009 earnings share expected to rise to 11.4% from -2.0% in 2008.
  • 12-month forward S&P P/E of 13.61 equates to earnings yield of 7.35% and is attractive relative to the 10-year T-note yield of 3.50%, but only mediocre relative to the 6.32% A-rated 10 year corporate.
  • Materials index weight is 2x its earnings share for 2009. Health care index weight well below its earnings share for both 2009 and 2010.
Earnings Shares and P/Es
Sector 2008% 2009% 2010% Market
Cap %
P/E
2008
P/E
2009
P/E
2010
Technology 16.95% 15.93% 15.58% 18.95% 14.5 17.9 14.8
Health Care 16.13% 18.14% 16.03% 13.63% 11.0 11.3 10.3
Cons Staple 12.91% 14.74% 13.08% 13.47% 13.6 13.8 12.5
Financials -2.01% 11.36% 14.56% 12.95% nm 17.2 10.8
Energy 23.17% 11.17% 12.93% 11.73% 6.6 15.8 11.0
Industrials 13.53% 10.76% 9.39% 9.64% 9.3 13.5 12.5
Cons Disc. 6.80% 7.34% 8.20% 9.17% 17.5 18.8 13.6
Utilities 4.50% 5.13% 4.48% 3.98% 11.5 11.7 10.8
Telecom 4.23% 3.88% 3.33% 3.38% 10.4 13.1 12.3
Materials 3.79% 1.55% 2.42% 3.10% 10.6 30.1 15.5
S&P 500 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 13.0 15.1 12.1

1247091863.JPG

1247091888.JPG

Neil Malkin contributed significantly to this report.

Data in this report, unless stated otherwise, is through the close on Tuesday 7/7/2009

Zacks Investment Research